Skip to content
PromptsBuddy
All episodes
The PromptsBuddy Podcast cover art
Season 1 · Episode 02July 17, 202645 min

Podcast episode

Designing with a critic that argues back

The PromptsBuddy Podcast

Using models as critique partners rather than generators — and why the work gets better the moment you stop asking for designs and start asking for arguments.

Audio drops soon

Designing with a critic that argues back

Why generated UI is a dead end for real products

Audio drops soon — subscribe and it lands when it goes live.

0:00—:—

Chapters

  1. 00:00Why generated UI is a dead end for real products
  2. 07:55The counter-argument round
  3. 16:30Behaviour, not feeling: how to phrase a critique request
  4. 24:40Two directions instead of twelve tweaks
  5. 33:20What still belongs entirely by hand
  6. 39:10Critiquing your own week-old work

Show notes

A year of asking models to produce interface designs is mostly wasted effort. The model generates the median of everything it has seen. The median is exactly what you do not want on a real product.

What works is inverting the relationship: bring your own work and ask to be argued with.

Generated UI is a dead end

Pretty frames are cheap. Product taste is not. When you ask for “a modern dashboard,” you get every dashboard average at once. Useful for moodboards. Useless for shipping.

The counter-argument round

Instead of “make me three options,” ask: “Here is my flow. Attack the weak steps. Name the user who gets stuck. Do not compliment anything.”

The model becomes a critic with infinite patience. You keep authorship.

Phrase the request as behaviour

“Make it feel premium” invites flattery. “A first-time user must complete invite in under two minutes without reading a tooltip” gives the critic something to test.

Two directions, not twelve tweaks

Ask for two mutually exclusive directions with reasons. Tweaking padding forever is how critique turns into noise.

What stays by hand

Final visual judgment. Brand voice. The decision to cut a feature. The model can stress-test your reasoning. It should not own the call.

Mentioned in this episode

#design#critique#ux#process

Prompts from this episode

Designintermediate

A design critique partner that argues back

Critiques a screen or flow against stated goals, then argues the opposite position — so you get a real second opinion instead of polite agreement.

ClaudeChatGPTGemini3 vars
Open prompt
Fundamentalsbeginner

Kill the flattery

A standing instruction that removes the praise, the restating, and the closing summary — so the reply is only the part you actually needed.

ClaudeChatGPTGemini1 vars
Open prompt